VPN for Streaming
Menu

Analysis

Which VPN speed tests for torrenting can be considered independent

The available excerpts do not make it possible to confirm the independence of any specific VPN speed test for torrenting. Such a conclusion requires a methodology, P2P measurement results and the conditions under which the test was carried out. A mention of a protocol, a promise of high speed or a message about a privacy audit does not in itself confirm this.

On VPN for Streaming Updated ~6 min

What the available excerpts allow us to establish

In the quoted passage from AV-Comparatives' 2020 report, ExpressVPN's protocols are listed; this quotation does not allow us to assess the methodology or the results of the torrent testing. In particular, the source mentions OpenVPN. This historical list cannot automatically be transferred to current apps and platforms.

We recommend assessing the test against the full report. The name of the laboratory helps to locate the publication, but to draw a conclusion about a specific test you need to read its conditions and results. The limits of an excerpt cannot be transferred to the content of the whole publication.

Advertised features describe connection conditions

A VPN config is imported into a compatible VPN client or onto a router that supports it. The torrent client then uses the established VPN connection. The configuration file itself is not loaded into qBittorrent.

Model testing scenarioProtocolAdvertised feature
Connection via a WireGuard configWireGuardCitadelVPN, configs in MAX
Connection via an OpenVPN configOpenVPNCitadelVPN, configs in MAX
Checking Lightway performanceLightwayExpressVPN, statement on the feature page

These scenarios help organise a comparison under chosen conditions. The order of the rows does not represent a speed ranking, and the presence of a protocol does not guarantee a download result.

How to tell whether a test is independent

Disclosure of affiliate links answers only part of the question

Independence of a test cannot be determined from a single disclosure of affiliate links. Such a disclosure indicates a potential conflict of interest. To assess it, you need to consider together the funding, the owner of the publication and the freedom to publish results.

Below are questions for assessing a specific publication. They do not describe any established relationship between a particular platform and a provider:

  • Who is the author, who owns the publication and who paid for the test?
  • Who chose the VPN, the servers and the connection parameters?
  • Did the provider grant special access or special terms?
  • Could it approve the material or forbid its publication?
  • Are affiliate links and other commercial ties disclosed?

The conclusion "the relationships are disclosed" differs from the conclusion "editorial independence has been confirmed". The absence of provider approval of the publication and of the choice of servers is considered alongside the other circumstances. Each such indicator on its own is insufficient.

What a torrent-speed test specifically must include

P2P means data exchange between participants in a torrent swarm. For a reproducible comparison, therefore, a description of the swarm itself is required, along with the VPN connection. An ordinary bandwidth measurement does not describe all the conditions of a torrent download.

Look for the following in the methodology:

  • A legally distributed test file, the characteristics of the swarm and the availability of participants.
  • The torrent client and its version, the operating system, the VPN protocol.
  • The location of the testing node and of the VPN server, and the date of the test.
  • A control run without the VPN at a comparable time.
  • Repeated measurements and the spread of results.
  • Separate download and upload figures, including seeding after the download.

These are criteria for checking a report, not a description of a test we carried out ourselves. For a reader in the UK, the location of the test node is especially useful: the results of another route cannot automatically be taken as a prediction for a home connection.

In practice. A model scenario for checking things yourself: suppose you are in London downloading a freely distributable Linux distribution. Compare the download without the VPN and through the selected server, keeping the other conditions unchanged, then repeat the measurements. Personal results characterise the chosen connection and swarm; on their own they do not confirm the independence of a published test.

In qBittorrent you can select the VPN interface: "Settings" → "Advanced" → "Network interface". Specify the interface of the established VPN connection and check the behaviour when it goes down. After changing the VPN client or the method of connection, the selected interface must be checked again.

A statement about the Lightway protocol does not determine speeds with port forwarding

ExpressVPN describes the Lightway protocol on its feature page. The advertised performance of the protocol and measured torrenting speeds cover different things. To compare speeds, you need results from a specific P2P scenario with stated conditions.

Port forwarding directs incoming connections to the required device or app. Setting up ports on a home router does not by itself establish support for incoming connections through the VPN. The terms for the router, the app and the servers should be checked separately in the official help documentation.

Before buying, look for a precise description of the P2P policy for the required platform and of the conditions for forwarded ports. A general page about P2P or the title of a guide does not confirm every mode of the service. From the excerpts quoted above, the speeds of Lightway with port forwarding cannot be established.

A privacy audit measures something else entirely

Messages about privacy and security audits do not in themselves confirm the independence of a speed test for torrenting. In the report you need to look at the object of the review, the date and the boundaries of its coverage. A review of a data retention policy answers a different question from measuring downloads and uploads.

A similar distinction applies to streaming. The adjacent article on how to test VPN streaming concerns a different VPN use case. Access to a region's catalogue cannot automatically be taken as proof of P2P speed.

You need the full report to name the fastest VPN

The available quotation from AV-Comparatives' 2020 report does not allow us to assess the methodology or the results of the torrent testing. The independence of any specific test cannot be confirmed from the excerpts quoted above. For a well-founded comparison, you need the full report, the funding and publication conditions, a control run without the VPN and repeated P2P measurements.

Read next

  1. Does CitadelVPN have UK servers for streaming ITVX abroad?
  2. Do speed tests show whether a VPN can stream 4K on Netflix and Disney+?
  3. What are NordVPN's limitations in 2026 for device limits, split tunnelling, port forwarding and torrenting?
  4. Do tests show a VPN gives enough speed for Disney+ 4K streaming?
  5. How do I stop my VPN dropping during large torrent downloads?

Sources used

AV-Comparatives' 2020 report (av-comparatives.org) · feature page (expressvpn.com)